Best execution

Spec sheet // Glossary // BEST EXECUTION
Glossary / B / Best execution
Glossary · GRC and resilience

Best execution

Also called order execution policy, execution quality

Definition

Best execution is the duty of a firm executing client orders to take sufficient steps to get the best possible result for the client. The result is judged on price, costs, speed, likelihood of execution and settlement, size and other relevant factors. Firms set an execution policy and check regularly that it delivers.

POLICYEXECUTEMEASUREREVIEW
Fig. 1 · Best execution
MiFID II Article 27 · Directive (EU) 2024/790 · COBS 11.2A and PS21/20
Key rulesMiFID II Article 27 · Directive (EU) 2024/790 · COBS 11.2A and PS21/20 · FINRA Rule 5310
Applies toEU investment firms executing client orders
RegionsUK · EU · US
01

How it works

A firm writes an order execution policy that sets out the venues and brokers it uses and how it ranks execution factors for each type of client and instrument. For retail clients total consideration, meaning price plus costs, usually decides the outcome. When an order comes in, the firm routes it in line with the policy and records the details needed to show the result was the best available at the time.

Monitoring teams then test execution quality, often with transaction cost analysis that compares fills against market benchmarks and other venues. Results go to a best execution committee, which reviews venues, brokers and the policy itself at least once a year. The EU and UK removed the annual public reports on top five venues and execution quality, known as RTS 27 and RTS 28, but the underlying duty and monitoring stay in place.

Step 1Set the policyChoose venues and rank execution factors by client type.
Step 2Route ordersExecute each order in line with the policy.
Step 3Record evidenceKeep order and market data to show the result.
Step 4Monitor qualityTest fills against benchmarks and other venues.
Step 5Review annuallyUpdate venues, brokers and the policy where needed.
02

The rules

EU · 3 January 2018MiFID II Article 27Directive 2014/65/EU on markets in financial instruments, Article 27

Requires firms to take all sufficient steps to obtain the best possible result for clients, set an order execution policy and monitor its effectiveness.

EU investment firms executing client orders
EU · 28 February 2024Directive (EU) 2024/790Directive (EU) 2024/790 amending MiFID II (MiFID II/MiFIR review)

Deletes the Article 27(6) duty to publish annually the top five execution venues and execution quality information, the RTS 28 report.

EU investment firms
UK · 1 December 2021COBS 11.2A and PS21/20FCA Conduct of Business sourcebook 11.2A, Best execution: MiFID provisions, as changed by Policy Statement PS21/20

Keeps the all sufficient steps duty and execution policy rules; PS21/20 removed the RTS 27 and RTS 28 reporting obligations from 1 December 2021.

UK investment firms executing client orders
US · 31 May 2012FINRA Rule 5310FINRA Rule 5310, Best Execution and Interpositioning

Requires reasonable diligence to find the best market for a security and to buy or sell there so the price to the customer is as favourable as possible under prevailing conditions.

FINRA member broker-dealers
03

Common questions

Does best execution mean the best price?

Not always. Price is usually the main factor, but firms must also weigh costs, speed, likelihood of execution, size and settlement. For retail clients in the UK and EU, the total cost to the client is normally decisive.

Do firms still publish RTS 28 reports?

No. The FCA removed RTS 27 and RTS 28 reports from 1 December 2021. The EU deleted the top five venue report in Directive (EU) 2024/790. Firms must still monitor and evidence execution quality.

Who oversees best execution inside a firm?

Usually a best execution committee with front office, compliance and risk members. It reviews monitoring results, venue and broker performance and the execution policy, and reports to senior management.