Conflicts of interest
Also called conflict management, conflicts policy
A conflict of interest arises when a firm, its staff or another client stands to gain in a way that could damage a client's interests. Regulated firms must identify conflicts, prevent or manage them through organisational controls, keep a record and, only as a last resort, disclose them to the client.
How it works
Firms map where conflicts can arise: proprietary trading against client orders, research alongside corporate finance, sales incentives, gifts and outside business interests. Each conflict is logged in a conflicts register with the controls applied, such as information barriers, separate supervision, remuneration design, or declining the business. A written conflicts policy sets out these arrangements, and senior management receives reports on conflicts at least once a year.
Disclosure is not a substitute for managing a conflict. In the UK and EU, a firm may only disclose when its arrangements are not enough to prevent the risk of damage to the client, and the disclosure must be specific and in a durable medium. In the US, Regulation Best Interest requires broker-dealers to identify and disclose or eliminate conflicts and to mitigate those that create an incentive to put their interests ahead of retail customers.
The rules
Requires firms to take all appropriate steps to identify and prevent or manage conflicts, and to disclose them clearly when arrangements are not sufficient.
EU investment firmsSet out the types of conflict to consider, the written conflicts policy and the record of services and activities that give rise to detrimental conflicts.
EU investment firmsRequires firms to identify, prevent or manage and record conflicts, keep a written policy reviewed at least annually and treat disclosure as a last resort.
UK authorised firms, with MiFID requirements restated in SYSC from this dateIncludes a conflict of interest obligation to identify and disclose or eliminate conflicts, and to mitigate those that create incentives to favour the firm.
US broker-dealers making recommendations to retail customersCommon questions
Is disclosing a conflict enough?
No. UK and EU rules require firms to prevent or manage conflicts first. Disclosure is a last resort when controls cannot remove the risk of damage to the client, and it must explain the specific conflict and risks.
What is a conflicts register?
A record of the conflicts a firm has identified, the business areas involved and the controls in place. Regulators expect it to be kept up to date and reviewed by senior management.
Do conflicts rules cover individual staff?
Yes. Personal trading, gifts and hospitality, outside business interests and incentives can all create conflicts. Firms control these through personal account dealing rules, gifts registers and declarations.
