Rocket Mortgage and Mr. Cooper Pay $6.75 Million to NYDFS
Rocket Mortgage will pay $2 million and Nationstar (Mr. Cooper) $4.75 million to New York’s financial regulator over Part 500 cybersecurity failures.
The New York Department of Financial Services (NYDFS) said on November 19 that Rocket Mortgage LLC will pay $2 million and Nationstar Mortgage LLC, which operates as Mr. Cooper, will pay $4.75 million for violating the state’s cybersecurity regulation, penalties that combine to $6.75 million.
Acting Superintendent Kaitlin Asrow announced the two separate consent orders, which cite breaches of 23 NYCRR Part 500, the regulation that sets minimum cybersecurity standards for banks, insurers, lenders and other firms licensed by the department. The NYDFS cybersecurity regulation penalties land on two of the largest US mortgage originators and servicers, and they turn on controls that most compliance teams already test: multi-factor authentication, incident notification, risk assessment and the handling of consumer data.
What the NYDFS cybersecurity regulation penalties cover
The Rocket Mortgage order rests on findings from an on-site examination in 2021. According to NYDFS, Rocket failed seven times between December 2019 and August 2021 to notify the department of cybersecurity incidents within 72 hours, the window Part 500 sets for reporting. In six of the seven cases, NYDFS learned of the incident only because examiners found it during that exam.
The department also found gaps in Rocket’s multi-factor authentication (MFA), which requires a second proof of identity beyond a password, and in its policies for securely disposing of consumers’ nonpublic information. Rocket agreed to pay $2 million and to strengthen the controls the order identifies.
The Nationstar order follows a real attack. In November 2023, criminals impersonated employees in phone calls to Mr. Cooper’s IT help desk and obtained temporary passwords, which they used to get into company systems and bypass MFA. NYDFS said the data exposed included Social Security numbers and birth dates for millions of people, among them hundreds of thousands of New York residents, and that online operations were disrupted for five days, leaving many customers without account access.
NYDFS also found that Nationstar had not completed a comprehensive cybersecurity risk assessment for almost four years before the attack. Part 500 requires covered firms to assess their risks periodically and to use the results to shape their controls, so a gap of that length removed the basis on which the company was meant to set its defenses.
Why the Part 500 findings matter to compliance teams
The two orders together touch four requirements that sit at the core of the regulation. They are timely incident reporting, MFA, a documented and current risk assessment, and written policies for protecting and disposing of customer data. A firm can fail the first without suffering a headline breach, as the Rocket findings show: the problem there was not a single catastrophic event but a pattern of incidents that did not reach the regulator on time.
Teams that run an incident notification clock will recognize the issue. The 72-hour period is measured from the point a firm determines that a reportable event has occurred, so the discipline lies in how quickly internal escalation reaches the people who decide and file. The Rocket order suggests examiners will test that chain against a firm’s own incident records.
The Nationstar findings bear on help desk procedures and on how firms treat MFA as a control that can be defeated through social engineering rather than through a technical flaw. NYDFS said the attackers got past MFA by obtaining temporary credentials from staff, which places identity verification at the help desk inside the scope of an examination.
Part 500 was amended with effect from November 1, 2023, and the amendments phased in stricter requirements, including MFA for all individuals accessing a covered entity’s information systems, with that deadline falling on November 1, 2025. Covered firms also file an annual certification of compliance or an acknowledgment of noncompliance with the department, which makes senior officers answerable for what the filing states. The conduct in these orders predates or overlaps the tougher MFA deadline, so the NYDFS penalties reflect the earlier version of the cybersecurity regulation.
How the penalties compare with earlier Part 500 cases
The figures are modest next to the largest Part 500 outcomes in recent years, yet they exceed the first full resolution under the rule. In March 2021, NYDFS announced a $1.5 million penalty against Residential Mortgage Services, Inc. for failing to report a 2019 breach on time and for lacking a comprehensive risk assessment. The same two failings appear in the new orders, which suggests the department’s focus has not shifted from the basics.
The $4.75 million Nationstar penalty is more than three times that 2021 figure, and the two orders together are more than four times it. The department’s consent order process lets a firm settle without a contested hearing, and the penalty is set with reference to the number of violations, how long they ran and the harm to consumers.
For boards, the pattern in enforcement actions of this kind is that regulators read control gaps as governance failures when they persist for years. A risk assessment that is almost four years out of date raises the question of who in management owned it and what the board saw in its reporting. Directors who want a framework for that conversation can start with the risk and cybersecurity priorities for boardroom executives.
What Asrow and the companies said
Asrow said New York’s cybersecurity regulation requires covered entities to maintain strong safeguards to protect consumer data, and that the department is committed to rigorous oversight to ensure regulated institutions protect consumers. She took up the acting superintendent role recently, and the announcement is among the first Part 500 actions under her name. NYDFS did not set out a wider list of enforcement priorities in the announcement.
A Rocket spokesperson said the company has strengthened its information security program, adopted a formal data disposal policy and enhanced monitoring, staff training and testing. Rocket said it entered two separate consent orders and that, as Mr. Cooper’s successor, it will follow the required information security controls and audits. Mr. Cooper did not provide a separate statement.
Remediation and what to watch next
Beyond the money, the orders require both firms to strengthen the controls that NYDFS found lacking. Rocket’s ownership of Mr. Cooper means the two programs now sit under one corporate parent, so the obligations in the Nationstar order, including the audits Rocket described, will be carried out inside a combined organization with a larger set of systems to assess.
The pairing of a two-decade-old servicer’s breach with a lender’s reporting failures gives mortgage firms a clear reference point for exam preparation. Both orders are on the department’s published enforcement list, and the full text is available through the NYDFS cybersecurity resource center.
The next checkpoint for covered entities under the cybersecurity regulation is the annual Part 500 certification, which NYDFS requires by April 15 each year for the preceding calendar year, and which will show how firms have treated the findings behind the penalties in these orders.

The go to weekly newsletter for compliance, risk, and governance professionals.
Trusted by 10,000+ industry leaders for authoritative RegTech intelligence, delivered weekly.
Join them today.
