OCC Raises Legal Concerns Over California Climate Disclosure Laws
The OCC asked California’s Air Resources Board to confirm that national banks and federal savings associations are outside two state climate disclosure laws.
The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) on October 29 sent a letter to the California Air Resources Board (CARB) urging it to clarify that national banks and federal savings associations are not required to comply with two California climate disclosure laws.
The OCC said the letter addresses “serious legal and policy concerns” raised by the laws. The move sets the federal charter regulator’s view directly against the California climate disclosure requirements for banks, 12 days before the first emissions reports are due under the state’s regime.
What the OCC asked CARB to do on climate disclosure
The OCC charters and supervises national banks and federal savings associations. The two laws at issue are understood to be California’s SB 253, the Climate Corporate Data Accountability Act, and SB 261, the Climate-Related Financial Risk Act.
The OCC said the laws would be inconsistent with OCC regulation and with safety and soundness. It said they would impose undue burden, particularly on smaller banks, and would harm California customers and disrupt customer relationships.
It also said the laws raise constitutional concerns, including under the Supremacy Clause, which makes federal law prevail over conflicting state law. The agency added that applying the laws to banks “may well run afoul of the legal framework for preemption and visitation.”
Preemption limits how far state law can regulate national banks. Visitation refers to the authority to examine and supervise them, which for national banks rests with the OCC. The agency called both “critical components of the dual banking system that Congress created over 150 years ago.”
Rather than asking CARB to delay the laws, the OCC asked it to clarify that banks under its charter are outside them.
Why the OCC’s position matters for banks
The OCC argued that applying the laws to federally chartered banks “is likely to decrease competition, drive up prices, and reduce Californians’ access to financial services.” It said this would harm residents and Main Street businesses.
For compliance teams, the practical question is whether national banks doing business in California must file emissions reports and climate risk reports under the state’s disclosure laws. The OCC says no.
The American Bankers Association (ABA) has separately told CARB in a letter that dozens of mid-sized and community banks across the US are likely to be required to file under the laws. The OCC’s concern about smaller banks mirrors that point.
Banks with California operations that sit under both regimes face a split. A state agency may treat them as reporting entities while their primary federal regulator says the state has no authority. Boards and audit committees that receive climate and board-level risk and compliance reporting will need to know which position the bank is working from.
How the two California laws work
SB 253 applies to US-based companies with more than $1 billion in annual revenue that do business in California. First-year reports cover Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions: direct emissions and those from purchased energy. Scope 3 reporting, covering value-chain emissions, begins in 2027 and is limited to five of the 15 GHG Protocol categories.
SB 261 applies to companies with more than $500 million in annual revenue. It requires a report on climate-related financial risk and the measures taken to reduce and adapt to it. It is a form of climate risk disclosure. Regulated insurance companies are exempt.
Both thresholds are measured on total revenue and applied at the entity level. A bank holding company with a federally chartered subsidiary would have to work out which entity is in scope. Intercompany transactions are excluded from the revenue calculation.
CARB must also collect annual fees from reporting entities. It has moved the fee-determination notice to December 10, 2026, and payment is due within 60 calendar days of that notice.
Where California climate disclosure rules for banks stand now
SB 261 is not being enforced. The US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit enjoined it on November 18, 2025, pending an appeal of the denial of a preliminary injunction. CARB has said it will not enforce SB 261 while that order stands.
The injunction does not cover SB 253. The Ninth Circuit heard oral argument on January 9, 2026, and the appeal is pending.
CARB approved its initial regulation on February 26, 2026. The Office of Administrative Law approved it on October 12, 2026, and it took effect immediately. The first SB 253 reporting deadline, originally August 10, is now November 10, 2026.
CARB has described its first-year approach as one that accepts good-faith efforts and best available data for Scope 1 and Scope 2 reports. It has said it expects to issue, by the end of 2026, a draft of further rules followed by a 45-day comment period. Proposals for 2027 include limited assurance over Scope 1 and 2 emissions, rising to reasonable assurance by 2030.
The OCC letter arrives after CARB’s approval of the regulation closed that process, so any exemption for national banks would have to come through CARB guidance or a later rule change.
The wider disclosure rulebook for large banks
Large banks with EU operations already face parallel reporting under the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive. CARB has said its 2027 framework is meant to be interoperable with IFRS S2 and the CSRD. Banks that file elsewhere may reuse that data for their California climate disclosure reports, if the state’s laws apply to them at all.
The OCC said it “will continue to monitor state law developments nationwide and act where appropriate.” The agency framed the letter as part of its commitment to ensuring that banks can engage in the business of banking “without improper interference of state laws.” The first SB 253 reports are due November 10, 2026, and CARB’s fee notice follows on December 10.

The go to weekly newsletter for compliance, risk, and governance professionals.
Trusted by 10,000+ industry leaders for authoritative RegTech intelligence, delivered weekly.
Join them today.
