Scenario analysis
Also called scenario testing, what-if analysis
Scenario analysis is a method for testing how a firm would be affected by a set of plausible future events or conditions. Unlike a forecast, it explores several possible paths, such as a severe cyber attack, a market crash or different climate pathways, to show where the firm's strategy, operations or finances are vulnerable.
How it works
Risk teams define a small set of scenarios, each a coherent story with specific assumptions, such as a key supplier failing for two weeks or carbon prices rising sharply. Subject experts then estimate the effects on revenue, losses, capital, liquidity or service delivery. Results are compared with risk appetite and impact tolerances, and the board reviews whether the firm needs to change its strategy, controls or buffers.
Scenario analysis is used in operational risk to estimate rare but severe losses, in operational resilience to test whether important business services stay within impact tolerance, and in climate risk to assess physical and transition risks over long horizons. It differs from stress testing in emphasis: stress tests usually apply a defined shock to financial positions, while scenario analysis explores a range of possible futures.
The rules
Requires entities to use climate-related scenario analysis, proportionate to their circumstances, to assess the resilience of their strategy and business model.
Entities applying ISSB standards, through local adoptionPrinciple 12 expects banks to use climate scenario analysis, covering physical and transition risks, to assess the resilience of their business models and strategies.
Internationally active banks and their supervisorsReplaced SS3/19 in full and sets expectations for climate risk management, including the use of scenario analysis to assess resilience.
UK banks, building societies, PRA-designated investment firms and insurersRequires firms to test their ability to remain within impact tolerance for each important business service in severe but plausible disruption scenarios.
Banks, insurers, payment firms and other firms in scopeCommon questions
What is the difference between scenario analysis and stress testing?
Stress testing usually applies a defined shock to a firm's financial positions to see if capital and liquidity hold. Scenario analysis explores several plausible futures, often qualitative, to find vulnerabilities in strategy or operations.
How many scenarios should a firm use?
Most firms use a small set, often three to five per risk area, covering a range from moderate to severe. Each should be specific enough to estimate impacts and relevant to the firm's business.
Why is scenario analysis used for climate risk?
Climate risks play out over decades and depend on policy and technology choices that are hard to predict. Scenarios let firms test their resilience across different temperature and transition pathways.
