No-action letter
Also called staff no-action relief, no-action position
A no-action letter is a written statement from a regulator's staff that they will not recommend enforcement action if a firm carries out a specific product, service or transaction as described. It is used mostly by the US SEC and CFTC. The relief covers only the facts presented and does not bind the regulator itself.
How it works
A firm or its lawyers write to the relevant staff division setting out the facts, the legal provisions in question and why they believe the activity complies or should not lead to enforcement. Staff may ask questions, require changes or conditions, or decline to respond. If they agree, they issue a letter confirming they would not recommend enforcement action on those facts, and the request and response are usually published.
At the CFTC, Regulation 140.99 separates no-action letters from exemptive and interpretative letters. A no-action letter binds only the issuing division and the named firm, and other firms cannot rely on it. SEC staff may let others rely on relief where their facts are substantially the same, and can withdraw or change positions later. Firms use published letters to read how staff see a rule before it is amended.
The rules
Defines no-action, exemptive and interpretative letters, sets how to request them and states that a no-action letter binds only the issuing division and the persons addressed.
Persons seeking relief from CFTC divisionsSEC staff state whether they would recommend enforcement action for a described activity; relief rests on the facts presented and staff can change positions.
Issuers, funds, advisers, broker-dealers and other persons subject to federal securities lawsLets the FCA give guidance to a single person on how rules apply to its own situation; the UK has no formal no-action letter regime.
Firms and other persons asking how FCA rules apply to their circumstancesCommon questions
Is a no-action letter legally binding?
No. It records the view of the regulator's staff, not the commission itself. Courts and the commission are not bound by it, and staff can change or withdraw their position later.
Can other firms rely on a no-action letter?
At the CFTC, only the named firm can rely on a no-action letter. SEC staff sometimes let other firms rely on relief where their facts are substantially the same. Interpretative letters are a broader tool that third parties can rely on.
Does the FCA issue no-action letters?
Not in the US form. The FCA gives individual guidance under SUP 9 on how rules apply to a firm's situation, and its innovation services offer informal steers to new business models.
