Spoofing

Spec sheet // Glossary // SPOOFING
Glossary / S / Spoofing
Glossary · GRC and resilience

Spoofing

Also called order spoofing, phantom orders

Definition

Spoofing is placing orders to buy or sell with the intention of cancelling them before they are executed. The orders create a false picture of supply or demand, moving the price so the trader can deal at a better level. It is a form of market manipulation in the US, UK and EU.

FAKE ORDERSPRICE MOVESREAL TRADECANCEL
Fig. 1 · Spoofing
CEA section 4c(a)(5)(C) · MAR Article 12(2)(c) and Delegated Regulation 2016/522 · UK MAR Article 12
Key rulesCEA section 4c(a)(5)(C) · MAR Article 12(2)(c) and Delegated Regulation 2016/522 · UK MAR Article 12
Applies toAny person trading on or subject to the rules of a CFTC-registered entity
RegionsUK · EU · US
01

How it works

A spoofer places one or more large orders on one side of the order book, often a few ticks away from the best price, so other traders see apparent buying or selling pressure. When prices move, the spoofer executes a smaller genuine order on the opposite side, then cancels the large orders. Layering is a variant that uses several orders at different price levels. The whole sequence can take seconds and is often run by algorithms.

Trade surveillance systems look for the pattern: large orders placed and cancelled at high rates, cancellations that follow fills on the opposite side, and order-to-trade ratios out of line with the trader's normal activity. Firms review alerts against the trader's intent, chat records and strategy. Confirmed cases go to the regulator as suspicious transaction and order reports in the UK and EU, and US firms report through their compliance and legal teams.

Step 1Capture ordersRecord every order, amendment and cancellation, not only trades.
Step 2Detect patternsFlag large orders cancelled soon after opposite-side fills.
Step 3Review intentCheck strategy, chat records and trader history.
Step 4EscalatePass suspected cases to compliance for a decision.
Step 5ReportFile an order report with the regulator where required.
02

The rules

US · 21 July 2010CEA section 4c(a)(5)(C)Commodity Exchange Act section 4c(a)(5)(C), 7 U.S.C. 6c(a)(5)(C), added by section 747 of the Dodd-Frank Act

Makes it unlawful to engage in spoofing, defined as bidding or offering with the intent to cancel the bid or offer before execution.

Any person trading on or subject to the rules of a CFTC-registered entity
EU · 3 July 2016MAR Article 12(2)(c) and Delegated Regulation 2016/522Regulation (EU) No 596/2014 on market abuse, Article 12(2)(c), with indicators in Annex II of Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2016/522

Treats placing, cancelling or modifying orders that give false or misleading signals or disrupt the order book as market manipulation; Annex II lists indicators of the practice.

All persons placing orders on EU trading venues
UK · 31 December 2020UK MAR Article 12Market Abuse Regulation as retained in UK law, Article 12 and Annex I

Keeps the same manipulation prohibition, including order placement, cancellation and modification, in UK law under FCA supervision.

All persons placing orders on UK trading venues
03

Common questions

Is spoofing illegal?

Yes. Spoofing is expressly prohibited in US commodity markets by the Commodity Exchange Act, and it is market manipulation under the market abuse regimes in the UK and EU. It can lead to fines, trading bans and, in the US, criminal prosecution.

What is the difference between spoofing and layering?

Layering is a form of spoofing. Instead of one large order, the trader places several orders at different price levels on the same side of the book to suggest depth, then cancels them all after trading on the other side.

Is cancelling an order spoofing?

No. Cancelling orders is a normal part of trading. Spoofing requires the intent to cancel before execution when the order is placed. Surveillance looks for patterns that point to that intent rather than single cancellations.