Off-channel communications

Spec sheet // Glossary // OFF-CHANNEL COMMUNICATIONS
Glossary / O / Off-channel communications
Glossary · GRC and resilience

Off-channel communications

Also called unapproved messaging, off-system communications

Definition

Off-channel communications are business messages sent by staff on channels their firm does not capture or archive, such as personal text messages or consumer messaging apps. Because the messages are not kept, firms breach recordkeeping rules and cannot supervise or produce them to regulators. The issue led to major US enforcement from 2021.

APPROVED APPSCAPTUREATTEST
Fig. 1 · Off-channel communications
SEC Rule 17a-4(b)(4) · CFTC Rule 1.31 · FCA COBS 11.8
Key rulesSEC Rule 17a-4(b)(4) · CFTC Rule 1.31 · FCA COBS 11.8
Applies toUS broker-dealers
RegionsUK · US
01

How it works

Broker-dealers, swap dealers and investment firms must keep records of business communications, including electronic messages. When traders, bankers or senior staff discuss deals or client orders on personal devices or apps the firm does not archive, those records are lost. Firms respond by approving specific channels, deploying capture tools on mobile devices, banning unapproved apps for business, collecting attestations from staff and testing compliance through device reviews and surveillance.

In December 2021 the SEC settled with a large broker-dealer over off-channel messaging, and in September 2022 it charged 16 firms with combined penalties of more than $1.1 billion, alongside parallel CFTC actions. Further rounds followed until January 2025. By the end of fiscal year 2024 the SEC had charged more than 100 firms and imposed more than $2 billion in penalties under the initiative. The recordkeeping rules themselves are unchanged.

Step 1Approve channelsName the messaging tools staff may use for business.
Step 2Capture messagesArchive approved channels, including on mobile devices.
Step 3Train and attestHave staff confirm they use only approved channels.
Step 4Test complianceReview samples and devices for off-channel use.
Step 5Discipline breachesAct on violations and record the outcome.
02

The rules

US · 22 December 1948SEC Rule 17a-4(b)(4)Securities Exchange Act Rule 17a-4(b)(4): Records to be preserved by certain exchange members, brokers and dealers

Requires broker-dealers to preserve communications relating to their business as such for at least three years, the first two in an easily accessible place.

US broker-dealers
US · 30 May 2017CFTC Rule 1.31CFTC Regulation 1.31, 17 CFR 1.31: Regulatory records; retention and production, as amended

Sets a general five-year retention period for regulatory records, including written communications, kept readily accessible and produced to the CFTC on request.

CFTC registrants including futures commission merchants and swap dealers
UK · 3 January 2018FCA COBS 11.8FCA Conduct of Business sourcebook 11.8: Recording telephone conversations and electronic communications

Requires firms to record relevant communications, keep them for five years and take reasonable steps to stop staff using private devices the firm cannot record.

UK investment firms carrying on relevant activities
03

SEC and CFTC off-channel enforcement sweep

The first large round came on 27 September 2022. The SEC charged 16 firms with combined penalties of more than $1.1 billion. Barclays, Bank of America's BofA Securities, Citigroup, Credit Suisse, Deutsche Bank, Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley and UBS each paid $125 million. Jefferies and Nomura paid $50 million each and Cantor Fitzgerald paid $10 million. The CFTC ran a parallel action the same day, ordering 11 financial institutions to pay $711 million, including $100 million from Bank of America and $75 million each from Barclays, Citi, Credit Suisse, Deutsche Bank, Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley and UBS.

On 14 August 2024 the SEC charged 26 firms with combined civil penalties of $392.75 million. Ameriprise Financial Services, Edward Jones, LPL Financial and Raymond James each paid $50 million, RBC Capital Markets paid $45 million and BNY Mellon Securities with Pershing paid $40 million. Three firms that reported their own violations paid far less: Truist Securities $5.5 million, Cetera Advisor Networks $4.5 million and Hilltop Securities $1.6 million.

The last SEC round under the initiative came on 13 January 2025, when 12 firms agreed to pay $63.1 million. Blackstone paid $12 million, KKR $11 million, Charles Schwab $10 million, and Apollo, Carlyle and TPG $8.5 million each. Santander US Capital Markets paid $4 million and PJT Partners paid $600,000 after self-reporting.

Enforcement has since cooled. In 2025 the SEC rejected requests from earlier settling firms to align their undertakings with the lighter January 2025 terms. In September 2025 the CFTC settled three off-channel orders with SMBC Capital Markets, Banco Santander with Santander US Capital Markets, and BNY Mellon, each at a $500,000 penalty after maximum cooperation credit. In May 2026 SEC Chairman Paul Atkins said at the FINRA annual conference that none of the off-channel cases involved investor harm and that the SEC would not bring such cases going forward. The recordkeeping rules still apply, and firms remain exposed to examination findings and to private litigation that relies on their records.

04

UK and EU position

MiFID II Article 16(7) requires investment firms to record telephone conversations and keep electronic communications that relate to orders and transactions. Article 76 of Commission Delegated Regulation 2017/565 adds detail on how firms record and supervise. Under the rules, firms keep the records for five years, and for up to seven years where the competent authority asks.

In the UK the FCA sets these requirements out in SYSC 10A. Firms must take all reasonable steps to record telephone conversations and keep copies of electronic communications relating to activities in financial instruments. The duty covers communications made on equipment the firm provides or has permitted staff to use for business. Firms must also take reasonable steps to stop staff using private equipment the firm cannot record or copy.

The FCA addressed messaging apps directly in Market Watch 66 in January 2021. It said the recording rules remain the same when staff work from home, and it flagged the risk of unmonitored or encrypted apps such as WhatsApp for sharing sensitive work information. Where staff use such apps for in-scope activities on business devices, the communications must be recorded and auditable. The FCA places no specific restriction on the apps firms can use. It expects firms to approve new channels before staff use them, to review recording policies regularly, to refresh training when policies or technology change, and to be able to show the regulator that they comply. Where recording is not possible, firms may need to ban personal devices for those activities.

05

Controls and archiving tools

Capture comes first. Firms list the channels staff may use for business, such as email, approved chat and collaboration tools, recorded voice lines and a managed mobile messaging app. They then connect each channel to an archive that stores the messages as records, with retention schedules that match the rules in each jurisdiction. Channels that cannot be captured are barred for business use.

Monitoring checks that staff stay inside those channels. Surveillance tools scan archived messages for risk terms and for references to moving a conversation to another app, and compliance teams sample devices and review alerts. Reconciliation reports compare the messages an archive holds with the activity of the source systems, which exposes gaps in capture.

Attestation completes the loop. Staff confirm on a regular schedule that they have used only approved channels, and firms keep those confirmations with training records, review evidence and the outcome of any breach. Regulators ask firms to show that policies are applied in practice, so records of reviews and attestations matter as much as the policy text.

Several vendors supply this stack. Smarsh offers Capture and Archive products and lists more than 100 supported channels, including mobile and social. Global Relay runs an enterprise archive covering email, messaging, collaboration, mobile and voice, with AI surveillance and reports on supervised users and policy coverage. Theta Lake provides unified capture, archiving and compliance review across voice, video and chat, with mobile capture and an archive connector for existing systems.

06

Common questions

Are messaging apps banned for business?

No rule bans a specific app. Firms must keep and supervise business communications, so they either capture an app's messages or prohibit its use for business.

Why did regulators fine firms for off-channel messages?

The SEC and CFTC found that staff, including senior managers, used personal devices and apps for business and the firms did not keep those messages, breaching recordkeeping and supervision rules.

Does the UK have the same requirement?

Yes. COBS 11.8 requires investment firms to record relevant phone calls and electronic communications and to take reasonable steps to prevent staff using devices the firm cannot record.